Sunday, January 19, 2014

Wind Energy Blows Away Records Across Europe, Driving Emissions and Electricity Prices Down


The data is in, and 2013 went out with a bang as wind energy output soared to new records across Europe. Electricity prices and air pollution dropped as wind energy drastically reduced fossil fuel use during high winter energy demand. Ireland, Denmark, Spain, Portugal, Germany, and the UK all saw noteworthy wind output records broken with no electric reliability problems. Below, we summarize the news that has just broken.

http://www.evwind.es/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Europe_wind_power.jpg
Ireland
The Emerald Isle is now green for two additional reasons, as wind energy reduced pollution and protected consumers’ pocketbooks from near-record natural gas prices by providing 24% of Ireland’s electricity for all of December. The Irish Examiner noted on Monday that “The sustained wind volumes forced expensive gas powered plants off the system and this provided downward pressure on wholesale prices.” It quotes an energy trader noting that “The substantial contribution of wind energy helped reduce the monthly average wholesale electricity price by 5%.” The article further explains that wind energy played a critical role in driving the price of electricity down despite near-record natural gas prices. At times wind energy has reliably provided 50% of the electricity in Ireland, which is particularly impressive for an island power system without the advantage of large power lines to import and export power to neighboring power systems. On December 5, the output from the country’s wind turbines peaked at a record 1588 MW, and another new record of 1769 MW was set at 6:30 PM on December 17.
Denmark
Long a leader in wind energy use, Denmark’s wind energy set a new record by providing a staggering 54.8% of the country’s electricity consumption for the month of December, as reported yesterday by the Wall Street Journal’s Market Watch. For all of 2013, wind energy provided around 33% of Denmark’s electricity. On certain days, such as December 21, wind energy generated more than 100% of the country’s electricity use, with the remainder exported across Denmark’s strong transmission links to neighboring countries.
Spain
Electric sector carbon dioxide emissions plummeted more than 23% in 2013 as wind energy grew to be Spain’s largest source of electricity, as noted last week in The Guardian. Wind energy provided 21.1% of Spain’s electricity for the year, beating out all other fuel sources to provide the largest piece of the country’s electricity mix. Wind drove the dramatic drop in CO2 emissions as natural gas power plant output dropped by 34.2% from 2012 and coal-fired generation fell by 27.3%, even though overall electricity use was relatively flat at a 2.1% decline.
As we and others have explained previously, wind has been the dominant factor driving Europe’s carbon emissions downward. Even though coal use continues to declineacross Europe, that hasn’t stopped fossil fuel industry groups, as well as some whoshould know better, from fabricating the myth of a coal resurgence by misleadingly exaggerating the completion of a few coal plants that were begun nearly a decade agoand a temporary blip in carbon emissions as Germany shut down its nuclear fleet.
Portugal
Portugal generated over 70% of its power from renewables during the first quarter of 2013, driven by a surge in wind and hydro power output. At times, Portugal has reliably produced more than 90% of its electricity from wind. Shockingly, we still hear fossil fuel-funded groups and other naysayers in the U.S. claim that it is not practical to reliably or efficiently exceed 10% (or some other made up number) wind energy on the power system. With glaring counterfactuals in many European countries and now many parts of the U.S., it is becoming increasingly hard for them to keep their heads buried in the sand.
Germany
As we’ve reported previouslyGermany’s old wind generation record was blown away on December 6, as wind-generated electricity peaked at slightly more than 26,000 MW. A news article explains: “The effect on [electricity] prices was also remarkable. In day-ahead trading, power prices on the exchange in Germany were only half of the levels in France and Switzerland, resulting in a large amount of power exports … Perhaps the most interesting thing about the storm in terms of wind power is that it shows how much more wind power capacity we can withstand. The record peak was still not even one third of peak demand at the time, suggesting that Germany might be able to have three times the current level of wind power–100 GW–installed before large amounts of wind power would have to be stored.” On December 24, German wind energy output came close to setting a new record.
The United Kingdom
We have previously reported that Britain set a new wind record of 6,053 MW on the morning of December 2, providing about 14 percent of the electricity on the U.K. system, according to Bloomberg News. The article said nearly 7,900 MW of gas-fired generation was shut down during the period of high wind, explaining that “wind and solar have no fuel costs, generally making them cheaper than coal or gas” and quoting an analyst that “it has given the chance for less efficient gas-burn facilities to drop output.”
A Business Green article this week provides additional updates on other wind records that were set in December.
“The facts speak for themselves – National Grid’s records tumbled one after another. Over the course of the week which began on Monday 16th December, wind generated a record 783,886 MWh – the highest ever for a seven-day period – providing 13 per cent of Britain’s total electricity needs that week.
On the Saturday before Christmas – a busy day for everyone and one when demand for electricity is high – we saw a record daily amount of power produced from wind with 132,812 MWh generated; a staggering 17 per cent of the nation’s total electricity consumption that day. Don’t forget that every unit of clean electricity generated by wind means one less unit is generated using expensive imports of polluting fossil fuels, so this represents a significant economic and environmental benefit for all of us.
The good news is, in fact, even better when we consider that the smaller wind farms that feed into local networks where the output isn’t recorded by National Grid would make the above figures at least 30 per cent higher.
The record-breaking trend has continued into the New Year with the highest half-hour contribution from wind on the transmission system having been achieved on the 6th January.”
Where does the United States fit in?
American wind energy continues to grow quickly, and many parts of the U.S. are now reaching wind output levels comparable to those seen in Europe. Iowa and South Dakota now produce more than 20% of their electricity from wind, and another seven states are above 10%. However, as shown in the DOE chart above, we could and should be doing more to cultivate the clean energy technologies of the 21st century.
Our wind plants are roughly 50% more productive than those in Europe on average, which yields a far lower cost of wind energy in the U.S. Our wind resource is far more diverse, and our power system far larger and more interconnected, making the reliable integration of large amounts of wind energy even easier. The total wind energy resource in the U.S., enough to meet our electricity needs roughly a dozen times over, is unmatched. Yet the lack of policy stability in the U.S. continues to inhibit the wind industry’s growth, as seen by the recent lapse of the wind production tax credit due to Congress’s inattention. Fortunately, that problem is fixable.

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Record German Wind Power

Record German Wind Power Lifts Renewable Share Over ’20 Goal


Record output from wind farms lifted Germany’s share of renewable electricity production above its 2020 target of 35 percent today as a storm from Scandinavia battered the nation’s northern coast.
 
A low pressure system dubbed Xaver, with hurricane-force winds of more than 140 kilometers (87 miles) an hour, hit the northern coastline of Germany today, according to the country’s weather service. Electricity produced by sun and wind supplied 27.2 gigawatts, or 36 percent, of Germany’s power at 1 p.m. Berlin time, according to the European Energy Exchange AG.

Germany is already Europe’s biggest producer of electricity from wind and sun and its newly formed coalition government agreed last month to get as much as 45 percent of electricity from renewables by 2025. The share of power from wind and solar rose to 49 percent on Nov. 9, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The average share of renewables in Germany across the whole of last year was 22 percent.

“Germany might already be meeting its 2020 target for some hours, but it would need a lot more installed capacity to average 35 percent over a year,” Gary Keane, principal consultant at Poeyry Oyj, an adviser to governments and utilities, said by phone from Oxford, England.

Wind output in Germany hit a record of 25.2 gigawatts at 1:45 p.m. and will account for 39 percent of supply at 11 p.m., according to EEX data.

Forced Shutdown

The strength of the storm forced turbines to shut down in some parts of Germany. The 48-megawatt Baltic 1 offshore wind farm operated by Karlsruhe-based EnBW Energie Baden-Wuerttemberg AG (EBK) automatically halted operations at 1 p.m. when winds became too strong, Friederike Eckstein, a spokeswoman, said by phone.

“Wind turbines can start to cut out when wind goes above 60 miles an hour, so with a storm there is an increased risk of that happening,” said Keane.

German power for tomorrow declined 10.3 percent to 30.79 euros ($42.05) a megawatt hour on the Epex Spot exchange in Paris at 5:22 p.m. That’s 38.63 euros lower than the same contract in neighboring France which settled at 69.42 euros a megawatt hour, the data show.

Wind and solar power are given priority access to the grid in Germany, meaning peaks in production can force coal and gas-fed plants to reduce their output. The proportion of power produced from conventional plants is expected to fall to 61 percent at 11 p.m., compared with 79 percent at 7 a.m. today, according to EEX data.

“The storm will also bring heavy gusts of wind to the Netherlands, Denmark and Poland until tomorrow afternoon,” Andreas Gassner, meteorologist at MMInternational, said by e-mail from Appenzell, Switzerland. “Denmark and Poland could see as much as 15 gigawatts of wind until early on Monday.”

Audubon report says wind turbines, wildlife can coexist in Maine

FALMOUTH — One of Maine’s top wildlife advocacy groups says there’s plenty of room in the state to accommodate animal habitat and wind energy development.

About 45 percent, or 418,000 acres, of the space with both adequate wind and low wildlife impact is found in the state’s expedited permitting areas designated for wind projects, stated the report written by wildlife biologist Susan Gallo.

The study comes as wind energy continues to receive steady attention in Maine, with the Board of Environmental Protection on Thursday scheduled to hear an appeal of an approved wind farm slated for Hancock County and some lawmakers still upset over the recent decision by Norwegian energy giant Statoil to drop its offshore wind plans here.

Late last month, the organization Environment Maine issued its own report on wind energy, finding that Maine generated a New England-best 884,000 megawatt-hours of wind power in 2012, an amount that displaced nearly 535,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuel plants.

Maine Audubon's 34-page report on wind energy’s potential conflict with the state’s wildlife found that, for the most part, it doesn’t.

The organization stressed that each proposed development site be reviewed individually for possible impacts on bird and animal species, but that in a general sense, there is a lot of room in Maine for wind farms to be erected without intruding on sensitive habitats.

As a result, the report stressed, there should be no reason why wind development takes place where it significantly affects wildlife.

“We recommend that any land-based wind development in the mountainous areas of northern and western Maine and along our coast be carefully studied,” the report stated, in part. “These regions stand out as areas with a lot of wind and wildlife resource overlap.”

Given current technology, Maine Audubon reports that the state would need to see wind development on approximately 15 percent of the windy acreage that does not overlap with wildlife resources in order to meet state goals of reaching the 3,000-megawatt capacity of land-based wind energy by 2030.

That production would provide power for between 675,000 and 900,000 homes, and would entail the construction of 600 more wind turbines, the report concluded.

Opponents of the wind energy buildout in Maine, including the group Friends of Maine Mountains, have argued that the turbines blemish the state’s pristine mountain ranges and are not as effective as other renewable energy sources, such as hydropower.
Maine Audubon acknowledged the concerns of wind power opponents and stated its findings did not eliminate the need for site-by-site reviews that take those concerns into account.

“The location and siting of wind developments is a complex issue, and while there is a broad array of important concerns – impacts to the local economy, tourism, outdoor recreation, regional power supplies, local residents, and scenic views – Maine Audubon has always focused its concern on wildlife and habitat,” the report stated.

Berlin energy demonstration

Berlin energy demonstration attended by 16,000


An estimated 16,000 protestors attended a demonstration in Berlin on Saturday, aimed at ‘saving’ Germany's Energiewende renewable energy policy from possible attack by the incoming coalition government.

Demonstrators marched under the united slogan “Save Energy Revolution: The sun and wind instead of fracking, coal and nuclear” as they attempted to get across a message of increasing renewable energy capacity and energy efficiency to lawmakers. The event included a symbolic protest on the lawn of the Reichstag.

While some commentators were pleased that the coalition deal struck between Angela Merkel’s union of Christian conservative parties and the centre-left Social Democratic Party (SPD) included ‘bandwidth’ targets for renewable energy generation, others felt the coalition deal would slow down the introduction of renewable energy capacity.

German Renewable Energy Association (BEE) spokesman Daniel Kluge attended the event. Kluge told PV Tech that the turnout was remarkable considering the weather was fairly poor and that the estimated turnout of 16,000 far exceeded the 5,000 to 10,000 protestors BEE had hoped to see.

Kluge described the event as colourful and while attendees marched under the banners of different organisations, all were unified by the one goal of persuading the German government to “enforce the exit of coal and nuclear”. Kluge said he felt the event sent a “good signal to the new government” and with “hard months” of uncertainty expected to lie ahead, the unity of different organisations coming together was very important.

Organisations involved in the demonstration included anti-nuclear group Ausgestrahlt, Friends of the Earth Germany (BUND), Greenpeace, representatives from companies including wind turbine manufacturer Enercom and associations for wind, solar and biogas industries. Democratic action website Campact, which bundles petitions and is used as a tool to mobilise campaigns, also hosted a petition.

Kluge said that despite the difficult political situation expected to face supporters of the Energiewende in coming months, the mood on the day was very positive. He also said that the timing of the demonstration to take place three days after the coalition deal was announced was also a coincidence that was “timed perfectly”. The agreed coalition deal has yet to be approved by the members of the SPD, who will decide its fate in a ballot on 15 December.

Saturday, November 30, 2013

250 Million Litres Of Toxins Every Day

What do Niagara Falls and the tar sands have in common?

Every day 250 million litres of toxic liquid waste is generated by the tar sands. That’s about as much water as pours over Niagara Falls in 90 seconds.

Big Oil is spending millions of dollars to greenwash the tarsands. It’s time for a much-needed reality check. Canadians deserve the truth about water and the tar sands. Watch our new video, Reality Check: Water and the Tar Sands, which sets the record straight. 
 
Want to know more? Check out our report: Reality Check: Water and the Tar Sands.

German Fossil Fuel Power Plants To Shut Down

Unable To Compete, German Fossil Fuel Power Plants To Shut Down

by John Johnston on 08/19/2013
Rooftop solar panels - GermanyIn a recent report released by RWE, the second largest electricity producer in Germany, the company has confirmed it is planning to withdraw 3.1 gigawatts of fossil fuel generating capacity from the electricity market.

RWE maintains that because there is a growing amount of renewable energy in Germany’s energy mix, wholesale energy prices have declined, so the company would be losing money if it had to sell power at the lower prices. A RWE statement explains, “Due to the continuing boom in solar energy, many power stations throughout the sector and across Europe are no longer profitable to operate. During the first half of 2013, the Conventional Power Generation Division’s operating result fell by almost two-thirds”.

The fossil fuel plants that are being talked about are not new plants, they are power plants that have already paid back the initial investment of building them, so it goes to show just how unviable they have become in the emerging era of renewable energy. Building new fossil fuel plants is all but out of the question these days.
Image CC licensed by Jim Winstead: Rooftop solar panels in Germany.
via Cleantechnica

Emus

Relax - wind farms aren't stressing out your emus

Posted Wed 27 Nov 2013, 3:28pm AEDT
What links the phenomena of allegedly stressed emus, dancing cattle and disoriented echidnas? Nothing but the ill-founded trend to blame anything and everything on wind farms, writes Simon Chapman.
 
Last week in Nova Scotia, the Canadian Atlantic province where midwinter temperatures fall to -20 degrees celsius, a small emu farm closed down. There's nothing unusual about this. Investment in emu farming was an ill-fated get-rich-quick bubble that burst in Canada over a decade ago. It has been described as a "failed industry".

But what made this sad story even sadder was that the husband and wife team behind it blamed the closure on wind turbines, saying they had seen many of their birds lose weight and die of "stress". Tellingly, no necropsies were performed, prompting one person to comment, "So they didn't have necropsies performed on any of the animals? That is extremely irresponsible farming. The department of Agriculture should be called in to inspect for animal cruelty."

As the picture illustrating this story shows, in Australia, where emus don't tend to be kept in pens and fed on pellets, the birds roam freely around turbines, among sheep and cattle.

But this morning in my email, a jubilant anti-wind-farm activist from rural NSW used the emu story to undermine the idea that wind-farm health complaints might be explained by negative thoughts about wind-farms, known as the "nocebo effect":
We were was also wondering if you know how the 'nocebo effect' works in emus? Is it a communicated disease and just how do the emus spread the word? Do you think if they paid the emus they may not have had a problem?
Nice try. But no cigar. Because if you peer just below the surface of these claims, there are obvious unanswered questions about effects on animals.

My ever-expanding collection of (now) 234 diseases and symptoms attributed to wind turbines includes many about animals. Some of the more interesting ones include reports of "dancing cattle" ("Cattle have been videotaped 'dancing' or lifting hooves repetitively from being shocked by electrical voltage in the ground" said to be leaking from wind turbines); bee extinction; a farmer opining that echidnas are disoriented by turbines, causing them to "dig up more soil looking for food than before and that they could pinpoint the location of their food source much more accurately back then (before turbines were installed)"; and the death of "more than 400 goats" on an outlying Taiwanese island.

Four hundred is a nice big number for goats, and oddly enough, it's the same number of goats that allegedly "dropped dead" in New Zealand! In Wisconsin, too, a farmer claims he lost most of his cattle herd after turbines were installed. Anti-wind-farm websites are awash with these astonishing claims that seem to have escaped the relevant authorities. Try searching for any official corroboration in government or official investigations and you'll be looking for a long time.

As anyone with even a passing familiarity with farming knows, mass or unusual deaths in livestock are of intense interest to governments because of concerns about infectious diseases with the potential to devastate the farming sector and export trade, or even lead to animal to human transmission. Concern about diseases like brucellosis, avian influenza and hendra virus see authorities isolate farms and destroy all remaining stock. Massive publicity follows. But when 400 goats unaccountably "drop dead" or a farmer reports lots of dead emus, these same government authorities are nowhere to be seen. It must be a conspiracy of silence.

All of the problems the anti's claim that wind turbines cause in humans occur in every community, regardless of whether they are near wind farms or not. Forty-five per cent of people report symptoms of insomnia at least once a week. Anxiety and depression are widespread. Getting old? Hair turning grey or receding? Eyesight, hearing, balance problems increasing with age? Putting on or losing weight? You need to know that all of these problems are apparently caused by wind turbines.

Many of the claims about animals fall into the same category. Yolkless eggs and those without shells are phenomena known to every poultry farmer, as this advisory site shows. But when such eggs are lain by chickens belonging to someone who doesn't like wind farms then Robert's your father's brother, it can only have been caused by the dastardly turbines! Dogs, horses, sheep, cattle, getting listless, skitty, off their food ... or anything really: wind turbines are to blame.

Every day in every country, thousands of people are diagnosed for the first time with one of countless health problems. They weren't having the symptoms that drove them to the doctor a few months ago, and now they have the diagnosis, they start thinking about what might have caused it. If they don't like the look of wind farms, or have been exposed to scary tales about all the things that can happen, and live near a wind farm, then the post hoc ergo propter hoc (after therefore because of) heuristic can powerfully kick in to make sense of the new problem.

Eighteen years ago, Australian news media were awash with stories of community panics about mobile telephone towers being likely to cause cancers. These never eventuated, with the age-adjusted incidence of almost all cancers in Australia flat-lining. Today, there are occasional reprises of this hysteria, but with the ubiquity of mobile phones, familiarity has calmed the situation. The current fringe hysteria about wind farms is likely to go the same way.

Simon Chapman AO is professor of Public Health at the University of Sydney and 2013 Australian Skeptic of the Year. View his full profile here.